Page 20 of 28
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2012 4:13 pm
by audifreakjim
JE pistons are nice, but they are way to expensive in my opinion. You might look into some other options. Wiseco, CP, etc.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2012 4:16 pm
by Longitudinal
I don't know if this is a good way of looking at it, but I think it's better to use a head gasket to do CR than to have too high a CR if those are your only choices.
I, too, don't care for large bores. With the limitations imposed by cylinder spacing, w just can't gain that much displacement from boring. My pistons will be a nice safe 82mm.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2012 4:50 pm
by 123quattro
Honestly I don't think you need to drop the CR. I'm running the same to more boost on less octane and no meth with no issues. If you want to run Diamond pistons I can get them to make duplicates of my 82mm units in a couple days supposedly now that mine are on file. They were ~$1200 for ceramic tops, friction coating on the skirts, Total Seal rings, spiral locks, and lighter wrist pins.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2012 6:34 pm
by EDIGREG
123quattro wrote:Honestly I don't think you need to drop the CR. I'm running the same to more boost on less octane and no meth with no issues. If you want to run Diamond pistons I can get them to make duplicates of my 82mm units in a couple day supposedly now that mine are on file. They were ~$1200 for ceramic tops, friction coating on the skirts, Total Seal rings, spiral locks, and lighter wrist pins.
Agreed - I run 9.3:1 and love it.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 1:56 pm
by chaloux
123quattro wrote:Honestly I don't think you need to drop the CR. I'm running the same to more boost on less octane and no meth with no issues. If you want to run Diamond pistons I can get them to make duplicates of my 82mm units in a couple days supposedly now that mine are on file. They were ~$1200 for ceramic tops, friction coating on the skirts, Total Seal rings, spiral locks, and lighter wrist pins.
Didn't you just say on the last page that you're running 8.5:1? Or do you mean not any lower than 8.5:1. The reason we want to lower CR is to allow the turbo to be in its sweet spot, which is likely above 30psi (I say likely because we don't have a map for it). With the ignition advance of the lower CR the CR drop isn't as significant a factor in driveability, as per PRJ and our own experience with this car.
Anyway, dad's shop neighbour (engine builder) is a Weisco dealer. He can get us a very nice deal on a set of coated pistons with rings etc. I think we're going to go that route with the same block with a new copper head gasket.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 1:57 pm
by chaloux
EDIGREG wrote:Agreed - I run 9.3:1 and love it.
PSHAW, you don't count Mr. E85

Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 2:06 pm
by loxxrider
Weisco seems to be pretty decent. I think Diamonds are pretty good too, but no first hand experience.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 5:24 pm
by 123quattro
Matt, I'm running 8.5:1. I meant I wouldn't go lower than that. What kind of timing numbers are you running? At 28 psi 5000 rpm is 21* and 7500 is 28* on mine.
Diamond makes really nice stuff, but generally they just do domestic V8 applications. I only went with them because they were local to me and came highly recommended by my machine shop.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 6:03 pm
by chaloux
This is (cough.. WAS) our spark map

Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 6:35 pm
by pkw
123quattro wrote:Matt, I'm running 8.5:1. I meant I wouldn't go lower than that. What kind of timing numbers are you running? At 28 psi 5000 rpm is 21* and 7500 is 28* on mine.
Diamond makes really nice stuff, but generally they just do domestic V8 applications. I only went with them because they were local to me and came highly recommended by my machine shop.
what do you run for fuel? octane? how many miles on this map and boost level?
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 8:27 pm
by Mushasho!
chaloux wrote:Anyway, dad's shop neighbour (engine builder) is a Weisco dealer. He can get us a very nice deal on a set of coated pistons with rings etc. I think we're going to go that route with the same block with a new copper head gasket.
Exactly what we spoke about 5 days ago, nice!... which rods are you slapping in there?
Sent from my NexusHD2 using Tapatalk 2
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 1:53 am
by chaloux
Mushasho! wrote:Exactly what we spoke about 5 days ago, nice!... which rods are you slapping in there?
The Pauters. I think. We'll see which weigh less

Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 2:09 am
by fasterthenrs2
How much those o rings stick out above the deck??? I did run copper hg twice both times it did got lifted, last time around I did put stock ml gasket bored to 83mm in with grate success ARP told me to TQ head studs to 75ft with they lube, and they told me to check tq after every 1k miles like 3 times and every time I got little more turn out of nuts.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 2:48 am
by chaloux
fasterthenrs2 wrote:How much those o rings stick out above the deck??? I did run copper hg twice both times it did got lifted, last time around I did put stock ml gasket bored to 83mm in with grate success ARP told me to TQ head studs to 75ft with they lube, and they told me to check tq after every 1k miles like 3 times and every time I got little more turn out of nuts.
Did you use The same block? What about their cutouts for the O rings? I think they stick out around .010
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 3:08 am
by fasterthenrs2
chaloux wrote:fasterthenrs2 wrote:How much those o rings stick out above the deck??? I did run copper hg twice both times it did got lifted, last time around I did put stock ml gasket bored to 83mm in with grate success ARP told me to TQ head studs to 75ft with they lube, and they told me to check tq after every 1k miles like 3 times and every time I got little more turn out of nuts.
Did you use The same block? What about their cutouts for the O rings? I think they stick out around .010
same block, what you mean by cutouts for o rings??? i did set up mine 5 thousands above the deck
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 3:30 am
by chaloux
You used the orings with the mls gasket as well then?
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 3:51 am
by fasterthenrs2
chaloux wrote:You used the orings with the mls gasket as well then?
yes
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2012 5:15 am
by 123quattro
pkw wrote:what do you run for fuel? octane? how many miles on this map and boost level?
pump gas, 93 octane, 15,000 miles at 28 psi. The difference might be that I pull timing aggressively as IAT goes up. Probably too aggressively, but it's lived so far.
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 8:22 am
by Longitudinal
OP, what was the CR in the first place on the stroker?
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Sun Apr 22, 2012 3:23 am
by chaloux
Jonathan wrote:OP, what was the CR in the first place on the stroker?
8.5:1
should have allowed us some headroom for boost
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 7:04 pm
by chaloux
So it turns out JE are pretty interested in the pistons with the 5 thou difference thing. They'll be receiving them shortly and we'll be getting an RMA #
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 8:17 pm
by EDIGREG
chaloux wrote:So it turns out JE are pretty interested in the pistons with the 5 thou difference thing. They'll be receiving them shortly and we'll be getting an RMA #
Nice! Maybe they'll send you a free set

Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Sat Apr 28, 2012 9:34 am
by pkw
did they overheat and shrink???
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Fri May 25, 2012 11:50 am
by chaloux
We're still in touch with JE. So far their assessment was: det = not our problem. Two interesting quotes from their assessment:
Boost pressure is not relevant to a tune being detonation inducing or not.
The compression ratio is not relevant to boost pressure, as the pressure is a measurement of restriction.
Once the pistons get figured out, the approach to the rebuild will be as follows:
Definitely
- 81.5mm pistons, 92.8 crank (2.4l)
- re-do turbo water/oil lines with proper AN fittings
- finishing details - fuel filter heat shield etc.
Maybe
- hank manifold and downpipe, possible white lightning coating
- Tial MVR 44mm wastegate
Who wants a Wagner SQ replica manifold? $800
Perhaps a CT3-6465 billet/ceramic ball bearing turbo? Was $1850 new. $1300? Absolutely perfect in every way, but needs a smaller hotside housing (comes with 1.0AR divided)
Re: Pops' 1997 S6 2.5L Stroker - pistons out
Posted: Fri May 25, 2012 12:01 pm
by EDIGREG
"Boost pressure is not relevant to a tune being detonation inducing or not." HUH? Of course it is, amongst many other variables.
You should move everything in the "maybe" category to the "definitely" category. Seriously, you will be soo happy with the setup.
What is the plan for a turbo?